Wednesday, January 21, 2009

15 Million Dollar Thought Tax!

by Beetle Blogger

15 Million Dollar Thought Tax
Taxing the Church to Feed the State

In what amounts to a free speech fine reminiscent of a scene out of Robin Hood, San Francisco City government is assessing a 15 million dollar tax on a tax exempt church. This thinly veiled retaliatory move for church involvement in the passing of proposition 8 is outrageous and clearly steps over the line in the separation of church and state.

Government has no say in church affairs, including what morality gets preached or how church officials and their parishioners vote. It doesn’t matter how unpopular the prop 8 vote was in San Francisco, government tax agencies can not be used as weapons to beat churches into submission, or cow them into silence.

Noam Chomsky said: “If you believe in freedom of speech, you believe in freedom of speech for views you don’t like. Goebbels was in favour of freedom of speech for views he liked. So was Stalin. If you’re in favour of freedom of speech, that means you’re in favour of freedom of speech precisely for views you despise.”

Separation of church and state is just that, freedom for the church to speak and act independently from government authority, and free from reprisal. This action by San Francisco City to quash the free exercise of speech and religion smacks of intimidation and corruption at City Hall.

Is the economy so bad, are budget issues so dire that we have to raid the donation coffers of the local parish, Mayor?

—Beetle Blogger

[Read full article here…]


  1. I'm impressed that so few folks in the US understand what the first amendment actually means in relation to church and state. By trying to completely secularize government, liberals have removed the backbone of our democracy.

  2. I think you're right, they treat the tax exempt status like a carrot, a handout to make the churches behave, but the tax exempt status is actually something that keeps the government from interfering in churches.

    If you use the tax status as a weapon against churches for behavior, thoughts, speech you don't like, then the barrier between church and state has been ruptured.

  3. Good points, L.B. & E. Religion needs to be protected, not blackmailed and threatened into "submission."

  4. It is the poor who suffer if the church has to pay massive amounts of tax.


This forum is open to anyone with a desire to express him/herself with respect, civility, and understanding. Please remember, therefore, that comments are not always reflective of the opinion of this website and its community. We reserve the right to delete any commentary or content, including, but not limited to, material that is obscene, profane, irrelevant, or otherwise inappropriate as per our discretion.